19. July 2010 21:06
The New York Times reports that affluent consumers, whose increased spending last year was largely credited with reviving hope in the US economy, may have now entered another period of retrenchment.
In November 2009, PSB released a report which looked at the general American population and identified a trend of increased spending among high income consumers. The headline result then was that Americans earning more than $70,000 a year planned to increase their holiday spending by 27% over the previous year, while those earning less than $40,000 a year were planning to reduce their spending by 14%.
The relative upswing in consumer sentiment forecast in our study, particularly among high income consumers, continued into the first half of 2010, and the article confirms that affluent consumers’ spending was on the up until very recently– hence the increase in sales of Mercedes and high end properties in the Hamptons and Manhattan mentioned in the Times article.
Indeed, for some time the hopes of US retailers, and the US economy in general, have been pinned on the continuing willingness of affluent Americans to maintain or increase their spending in 2010. The latest data, therefore, is likely to leave many businesses nervous about the ongoing unpredictability of the American consumer.
The picture becomes even more nuanced when one considers today’s Politico poll, also conducted by PSB. This survey suggests that 45 percent of “Washington elites” feel the country and the economy are headed in the right direction, while only 25 percent of the general population feels that way. What is not clear, however, is how the spending patterns of Elites will be affected by these higher confidence levels.
In such a perplexing environment, companies may need to take the temperature of their customers more often than they have historically. One month of disappointing data, particularly if it emanates from higher end consumers, is proving itself able to undermine confidence everywhere, so companies should be looking to research their customers’ spending patterns, as well as their general sentiments, as often as possible.